Indianapolis Toy Stores: A Parent's Guide on Where to Shop

Disclosure: This post may contain affiliate links, to find out more information, please read my disclaimer.

Proof Prints by Indianapolis Family Photographer

As an Indianapolis mom, visiting a toy store feels like entering a magical world where you can find almost everything your child wants. Indianapolis is home to many toy stores offering a vast collection of toys that would keep your child entertained for hours. However, finding the perfect toy store that caters to your child’s needs may seem daunting. But have no fear because, in this blog post, I will guide you through some of the best Indianapolis toy stores.

Kits & Kaboodle Classic Toys in Carmel

If you’re looking for a toy store that’s a little off the beaten path, Kits & Kaboodle Classic Toys in Carmel might just be the place for you. This hidden gem carries various toys, from classic board games and puzzles to dress-up clothes and art supplies. Don’t let the name fool you – Kits & Kaboodle isn’t just for kids. The store carries plenty of nostalgic toys that adults will love too. And the best part? You don’t have to travel into downtown Indianapolis to find it! If you want a fun and unique shopping experience, head north to Carmel and check out Kits & Kaboodle Classic Toys.

The Toy Pit

The Toy Pit is a perfect destination if you’re looking for collectible action figures or vintage toy finds. This toy store features collectibles from famous TV shows and movies like Star Wars, Transformers, and Marvel. With over 5,000 square feet, there is something for everyone. Here, you can also find rare vintage toys, board games, and comics. You can even trade in your old toys for cash.

baby 1 year birthday photo session Indianapolis family photo

Children’s Museum Store

The Children’s Museum of Indianapolis is the world’s largest children’s museum and is home to some of the most unique and interactive exhibits for children. So, it’s only fitting that the museum’s store offers an extensive collection of toys that promote learning and play. It features educational toys, puzzles, books, STEM activity kits, plush toys, and souvenirs.

The LEGO Store Castleton

If you’re searching for a great toy store in Indianapolis, look no further than The LEGO Store Castleton. This place isn’t just your average toy store; it’s an entire experience. The brightly lit store is filled with shelves brimming with LEGO sets of every kind imaginable, and their themed displays are undoubtedly a sight to see. Whether you’re looking to build the most fantastic Star Wars spaceship or are in the market for a timeless LEGO classic, you’ll find it all here. The friendly staff is always ready to help you find exactly what you want. Don’t miss out on this fantastic destination for LEGO enthusiasts of all ages!

Studio session of a family of 4 lifestyle pose

Mom and toddler girl in studio photo session

Online Toy Stores

Online toy stores have revolutionized the way we shop for toys. Nowadays, you don’t have to leave the comfort of your home to find the perfect gift for your child. These options are great if you have a slight lead time to account for shipping. Here are some of my kids’ favorites:

Lovevery Play Kits: These subscription boxes are specifically curated for your child’s developmental stage, making providing engaging toys and activities easy and convenient. From sensory games to puzzles, the Lovevery Play Kits promote cognitive and motor skill development while keeping your little one entertained. Plus, with a new kit delivered every few months, you can ensure your child is constantly challenged and stimulated.
Montessori Toys on Amazon encourages exploration, imagination, and problem-solving skills. From wooden stackers to shape sorters, Montessori toys are fun and promote independent and self-directed learning. Plus, with Amazon’s convenient delivery options, you can deliver these educational toys right to your doorstep.
Etsy Montessori Climbing Arch: Have you ever watched a toddler scale a playground structure with sheer determination and excitement? It’s truly a sight to behold. The Montessori Climbing Arch is like a mini playground in your home – perfect for little ones to practice their motor skills and build confidence in a safe and controlled environment.